California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress Reading Grade 11

Eighteen grade 11 passages and 108 questions. Each passage has its own questions on argument, evidence, and what the text says.

These questions are original. This is not an official California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress test, and FreeExam is not affiliated with the California Department of Education.

Article Four of the Cedar Row Charter

The Cedar Row Debate Society is a student club, and the charter is a set of rules the members wrote for themselves. Article 4 states the voting rule in one sentence. A motion passes only if more than half of the members present vote yes. Members who are absent are not added to the number present. The half is taken from the people in the room.

At the March meeting, 11 members were present. Half of 11 is 5.5. More than half means a yes count greater than 5.5, so 6 yes votes pass, and 5 yes votes do not. The March motion received 6 yes votes. Under Article 4, that motion passes.

The May meeting had the same number in the room: 11 members present. The May motion received 5 yes votes. Five is not more than half of 11, so the May motion does not pass. A member who wants the absent names added into the 11 is reading a rule the charter does not contain. Six yes votes pass. Five yes votes do not.

  1. 1.When 11 members are present, which result follows from Article 4?

  2. 2.What does Article 4 do with members who are absent?

  3. 3.Why does the May motion fail?

  4. 4.In the last paragraph, what does added into the 11 mean?

  5. 5.How do the March and May results differ?

  6. 6.Which detail shows that the half is taken from the people in the room?

Nearest in January

A handout from the Ridge Planetarium corrects a guess students often make about the seasons. Earth's path around the sun is slightly oval, so the distance from the sun is not the same all year. Earth is closest to the sun in January. In July the planet is farther from the sun.

A northern winter still happens in January. The handout names the cause as tilt, not distance. In January the Northern Hemisphere leans away from the sun. Sunlight arrives at a lower angle, and the daylight is shorter, so that hemisphere receives less warming light even though the planet is at its nearest point.

Distance is one fact about the whole planet at a single time. It cannot, by itself, chill one hemisphere and warm the other. In that same January the Southern Hemisphere leans toward the sun and has its warmer season. If a shorter distance were what made a hemisphere warm, both hemispheres would warm together in the month when Earth is closest to the sun. They do not. Tilt sets the seasons opposite each other. January nearness and the northern winter share a month. They do not share a cause.

  1. 7.According to the handout, why does a northern winter still happen in January?

  2. 8.When is Earth closest to the sun, according to the handout?

  3. 9.If a shorter distance made a hemisphere warm, what does the handout say January would show?

  4. 10.What does the handout say January sunlight does in the Northern Hemisphere?

  5. 11.In the handout, what does slightly oval explain?

  6. 12.What do January nearness and the northern winter share, according to the handout?

West Hall, Counted

Memorandum. To the events desk. From Imani Cole, building manager. Subject: How many people West Hall can seat.

West Hall is arranged in a fixed grid. There are 12 rows, and each row has 40 seats. The seats are bolted down. A booking cannot add a thirteenth row, and it cannot add a forty-first seat to a row.

Use the product rather than last year's poster. Forty seats in each of 12 rows means the hall holds 480 people. A request for 500 does not fit. A request for 480 fills every seat and leaves none unused.

If a row is closed for repair, count only the open rows before you confirm the date. The figure 480 applies when all 12 rows are open, with 40 seats in each. It is not a wish, and it is not the capacity of the lobby. This memo does not give a lobby count.

  1. 13.What does the memo say about how many people West Hall holds?

  2. 14.How does the memo get the figure 480?

  3. 15.Why does a request for 500 people fail to fit?

  4. 16.What count does the memo refuse to give?

  5. 17.What should the events desk do if a row is closed for repair?

  6. 18.What does bolted down tell the events desk about the seats?

The Bowl on the Bench

1 The garden gate sticks in the minute the sprinklers stop.

2 I put a shoulder to it, and the latch answers late.

3 Bean vines hang on twine that sags between the stakes,

4 a low curve, as if the row had let out a breath.

5 A paper sign calls the plots resting.

6 Resting is a polite word for a rule: no picking after nine.

7 Someone has left a bowl of cherry tomatoes on the bench,

8 a small bright objection set beside the sign.

9 I leave the bowl where it is.

10 A bowl is not an exception the sign agreed to.

11 The sign remains the rule, and the fruit remains in the bowl.

12 I take the late click of the latch with me, and nothing else.

  1. 19.What rule does line 6 state?

  2. 20.What does the speaker do with the bowl of tomatoes?

  3. 21.How do lines 10 and 11 treat the bowl?

  4. 22.In line 4, what is the phrase let out a breath describing?

  5. 23.What does line 12 say the speaker takes away?

  6. 24.In line 6, what does polite suggest about the word resting?

Keep the Tenth Hour

The student senate should keep the library open for a tenth hour, until 9 p.m., on weeknights during the term. The extra hour costs a student wage and a utility bill. I am not calling that cost imaginary. The budget office priced it at the March hearing, and that price is real.

The hour still belongs on the calendar because the only quiet seats after sports practice are in that building. The March count, taken on four weeknights, found the reading room above 80 percent full at 8:15 p.m. A room that full at 8:15 is evidence that the ninth hour is not spare capacity. It is not evidence about weekend mornings, and I am not using it that way.

The opposing letter says students can study in the cafeteria. The cafeteria closes its kitchen at 7 and stacks the chairs at 7:30. A room that is already stacked is not an alternative to a room that is still open. The letter names a place and skips the hour when that place can no longer be used.

Keep the tenth hour through the term. Revisit the wage in June with a new count. Do not end the hour in April on the claim that a room which shuts at 7:30 is available.

  1. 25.What cost does the writer concede?

  2. 26.What does the March count support?

  3. 27.What does the writer say the March count does not show?

  4. 28.Why is the cafeteria a weak alternative in this argument?

  5. 29.What action does the writer recommend?

  6. 30.In this argument, what does spare capacity mean?

One Saturday on the East Platform

A memo from a transit intern argues that riders have abandoned the east platform. The evidence offered is one Saturday in April. A counter recorded 30 boardings on the east platform and 90 on the west platform.

The number 30 is a real count for that Saturday. It describes that day. It does not describe a year, and it does not name a cause. The memo adds that people dislike the east platform. Dislike is a motive. The count shows fewer boardings on one date. It does not show why those boardings were fewer.

A note from the station chief, attached under the memo, says the east elevator was locked for repair that Saturday. The note is a possible explanation for a low count on that date. It is not proof that riders have permanently left the platform. A locked elevator on one Saturday can lower that day's number without settling the larger claim.

A careful sentence stops where the count stops: on that Saturday, with the elevator locked, the east platform had 30 boardings and the west had 90. The jump from that sentence to a claim of abandonment treats one constrained day as a lasting preference.

  1. 31.What did the counter record?

  2. 32.Why does the count fail to show that people dislike the east platform?

  3. 33.What does the station chief's note add?

  4. 34.What reasoning flaw does the passage identify in the intern's claim?

  5. 35.Which sentence does the passage call careful?

  6. 36.What does the passage say the number 30 does not describe?

The Book Still on the Desk

The excerpt is from The Second Copy, a short play set in a classroom after the bell. The borrowed book is a blue paperback. Maris enters carrying a shop bag.

MARIS: I brought it back. Your copy is returned.

(Maris sets a different book, still in the shop bag, on the windowsill. The borrowed blue paperback remains on the teacher's desk. Maris does not touch it.)

ELIAS: Then the record is clear.

MARIS: I said I brought it back.

ELIAS: The one you borrowed is still on my desk.

The spoken claim is that the copy was returned. The stage direction puts a different book on the windowsill and leaves the borrowed paperback on the desk. A reader who keeps only Maris's line will think the borrowed copy came back. The direction shows it did not. In this scene the direction is the more reliable report of where the borrowed book is, because it shows the two books in two places, while the line only claims a return.

  1. 37.What does Maris claim out loud?

  2. 38.What does the stage direction show about the two books?

  3. 39.What does Elias's last line point out?

  4. 40.What mistake does a reader make by keeping only Maris's spoken line?

  5. 41.Why does the passage treat the stage direction as the more reliable report?

  6. 42.How does Elias's line "Then the record is clear" sit against the ending?

A Named Reader, Before Publication

The research guide for the senior seminar defines peer-reviewed before the class may use the phrase. A source is peer-reviewed when a named reader, other than the author, examined the piece before publication and the publication says so. A name on a byline is the author, not that reader. Popularity is not the test.

In a sample project the guide discusses, a student calls a travel blog peer-reviewed because thousands of people liked it. The blog names its author. It does not name a reader who examined the piece before publication. Under the guide's definition, the blog is not peer-reviewed. Likes do not supply the missing reader.

The student may still cite the blog as a personal account. That would be a different label, about experience. It would not be the label the guide reserved for a named reader's examination before publication. Calling the blog peer-reviewed borrows a standard the guide already attached to a stricter process.

  1. 43.How does the research guide define peer-reviewed?

  2. 44.Why is the travel blog not peer-reviewed under the guide?

  3. 45.What does the guide say popularity cannot do?

  4. 46.What may the student still do with the blog?

  5. 47.According to the guide, what is a name on a byline?

  6. 48.What error does the guide find in calling the blog peer-reviewed?

The Minute and the Request

Two pieces ran the morning the plaza fountain stopped. They do different work.

Desk note, written by the facilities clerk at 7 a.m.: The plaza fountain stopped circulating at 6:40 a.m. A valve in the pump room was closed. The clerk confirmed the time and said a technician would inspect the valve before noon. The note records a stoppage and a closed valve. It does not tell the council to replace the pump.

Column printed beside the note: The fountain is the plaza's public center, and the council should replace the pump this quarter rather than patch the valve again. A replacement is a choice about the quarter's budget. The column asks for that choice. It does not establish the minute the water stopped.

A record and a recommendation can share a page and keep separate jobs. The sentence that the fountain stopped at 6:40 can be checked against the clerk. The sentence that the council should replace the pump stands or falls as an argument about money. The time is not a budget request, and the request is not a clock.

  1. 49.According to the desk note, when did the fountain stop circulating?

  2. 50.What condition in the pump room does the desk note record?

  3. 51.What does the desk note not do?

  4. 52.What does the column ask the council to do?

  5. 53.What does the column not establish?

  6. 54.How does the passage distinguish the two pieces?

Fourteen Voices at One Lunch

A flier from a snack cart in the school courtyard opens with a count that is real. During one lunch, the owner asked 14 students whether they wanted the cart to stay. Eleven said yes. Three said no.

The flier then prints a wider sentence: the district wants the cart to stay. The district did not answer the question. Fourteen students at one lunch are not the district. Eleven of 14 describes that group on that day. Changing the noun to district makes the count carry a population it never measured.

The arithmetic of 11 and 3 can be accepted, and the leap can still be rejected. A later survey, taken in more than one school and on more than one day, might support a wider sentence. This flier does not contain that survey. Its honest reach stops at the 14 students. The word district is doing work the lunch count never earned.

  1. 55.What count does the flier actually report?

  2. 56.What is the flaw in the sentence about the district?

  3. 57.What does the passage say can be accepted even while the leap is rejected?

  4. 58.What does the passage say a wider sentence would need that this flier lacks?

  5. 59.Where does the passage say the flier's honest reach stops?

  6. 60.In the last sentence, what does earned mean?

A Roof over the Southbound Stop

I am asking the route board to put a roof over the southbound stop on Keller Avenue. I will name the cost first. A simple roof, quoted in the April packet, is 2,400 dollars, and that money cannot also buy a new bench at the north stop. I am treating the tradeoff as real.

The opposing note calls a roof a luxury because people already have hats. Hats are personal gear. They do not shade a public stop at noon, and they do not belong to the rider who arrived without one. The note answers a request for a structure with a suggestion about clothing.

The July log, kept by the driver on ten school days, records riders waiting at the southbound stop at noon on each of those days. The log shows use at the hot hour. It does not show that a roof would lower the temperature by any stated number of degrees, and I will not invent that number. Use is the evidence I have. A temperature claim would need a measurement this letter does not contain.

Fund the roof from the stop budget. Leave the north bench for a separate request. Do not answer a missing roof with a sentence about hats.

  1. 61.What tradeoff does the writer treat as real?

  2. 62.What does the July log show?

  3. 63.What temperature claim does the writer refuse to make?

  4. 64.Why does the writer reject hats as an answer to the request?

  5. 65.What does the writer ask the route board to fund now?

  6. 66.How is the word luxury used in this letter?

The Piece Named on the Program

A review of the Thursday concert begins in admiration. The reviewer praises the quartet's control in the slow movement and the way the cello line stayed audible under the violins. That opening reports a performance that happened.

The printed program listed an encore by name: Harbor Air. The reviewer waited for it. The musicians bowed and left. Harbor Air was not played. The review then turns. A program that names a piece makes a promise to the audience that bought a ticket from that program. Skipping the piece without a word breaks the promise. The praise for the slow movement remains. It does not repair the unplayed name.

The last sentence is the sharp one. It tells the musicians to play what they printed, or to print what they played. The sentence aims at the mismatch, not at the intonation. A reader who quotes only the praise will miss the turn. The note holds both, and the ending shows which one the reviewer now weighs more.

  1. 67.What performance does the review praise?

  2. 68.What happened to Harbor Air?

  3. 69.What promise does the reviewer attach to a named piece on the program?

  4. 70.Does the praise for the slow movement repair the unplayed encore?

  5. 71.What does the last sentence demand?

  6. 72.What does a reader miss by quoting only the praise?

The Third Step on the West Stair

I am speaking for the maintenance request on the west stair, and I am going to stay with the tread that split. On October 2 a student caught a heel in a crack on the third step. The nurse's log records a scraped ankle and an ice pack. That log is the evidence for a repair. It is not a story about the building's personality, and I will not decorate it.

The opposing comment calls the request a luxury because the stairs still function. In that comment, function means that people can go up. It does not mean the crack is gone. A stair that can be climbed and a stair that is sound are different claims. The comment treats the first claim as if it had answered the second.

I am asking for the replacement priced in the facilities packet: four treads on the west stair, not a redesign of the lobby. If the packet's price is too high, say so and give a number. Do not answer a cracked step by calling the repair a luxury. A scraped ankle on October 2 is a reason to replace the damaged tread. It is not a reason to repaint the handrails, and I am not asking for paint.

  1. 73.What evidence does the speaker use for the repair?

  2. 74.What does the speaker ask the hearing to fund?

  3. 75.How does the speaker answer the claim that the stairs still function?

  4. 76.Which request does the speaker say is not part of this appeal?

  5. 77.Whose word is luxury in this speech?

  6. 78.What kind of objection does the speaker say would address the packet?

Three Feet at Four o'Clock

The town gauge at Marker Six reports how high the creek stands at the moment of the reading. On Thursday at 4 p.m. the gauge read 3 feet. Three feet is a height. It is not a forecast, and it is not a history of the whole month.

A post on the neighborhood board said the gauge proves the creek will flood on Sunday. A single Thursday reading cannot prove a Sunday flood. A flood would depend on rain that has not yet fallen, on the condition of the ground, and on what the creek does between Thursday and Sunday. The gauge does not contain those later facts.

The same post said the reading shows the creek is always dangerous. Always is a claim about every season. One afternoon in one week cannot carry the word always. The honest sentence is narrower: at 4 p.m. on Thursday, Marker Six stood at 3 feet. A later reading could be higher or lower. Until that reading exists, the Thursday number remains the Thursday number.

  1. 79.What did Marker Six report on Thursday at 4 p.m.?

  2. 80.Why can the Thursday reading not prove a Sunday flood?

  3. 81.Why does the passage reject the word always for this reading?

  4. 82.Which set of facts does the passage say a flood claim would still need?

  5. 83.What is the honest sentence the passage allows?

  6. 84.What does the passage say about a reading taken after Thursday?

Written at 8:12

On the night of the auditorium alarm, the duty log was written at 8:12 p.m. by the person standing at the door. It says the alarm sounded at 8:05, the hall was cleared by 8:09, and no one reported an injury. The log is timed, and it limits itself to those three statements.

A week later, a letter to the school paper says the alarm threw the hall into a panic and that several students were hurt. The letter was not written at 8:12. It adds panic and injuries. The duty log records neither one. A later memory can be sincere and still add events the timed log does not contain.

A reader who treats the two texts as equal reports of the injuries is skipping the difference in time and in contents. The log can support a sentence about the alarm time, the clearing time, and the absence of a reported injury in that record. It cannot support the letter's word several. The letter can show what its writer believed a week later. It cannot, by itself, overwrite the log's statement that no one reported an injury.

  1. 85.When was the duty log written?

  2. 86.Which three statements does the duty log limit itself to?

  3. 87.What does the letter add that the log does not record?

  4. 88.Why does the passage say the two texts are not equal reports of the injuries?

  5. 89.What can the log support, according to the passage?

  6. 90.What does the passage mean by saying the letter cannot overwrite the log?

Held, Not Hosted

The city desk's first headline said the visiting players were hosted at the station for three hours. The reporter's notebook, drawing on the duty log, uses a different verb. The log says the players were held from 4 p.m. until 7 p.m. and were not free to leave.

Hosted suggests a welcome. Held, as the log uses it, says they could not go. The two verbs cover the same three hours and do not describe the same condition. A headline that keeps hosted borrows a courtesy the log does not record.

The editor's comment in the margin is specific. If the log had said the players were free to tour the station, hosted could stand. The log says they were not free to leave, so the verb has to be able to say that. The change from hosted to held answers the log. A wish for a softer front page is not the reason the comment gives.

  1. 91.What did the first headline say about the players?

  2. 92.What condition does the duty log record?

  3. 93.Why is hosted a misleading verb for this log?

  4. 94.When does the editor say hosted could stand?

  5. 95.What reason does the editor's comment not give for the change?

  6. 96.What standard makes the revision to held acceptable in this passage?

Before the Lock

The school gate locks at 5:15 p.m. The late bus leaves at 5:10 from the stop outside, while the gate is still open. On Tuesday Jonah missed that bus. He was in the stairwell watching the end of a game and did not start for the door until 5:12. He reached the gate at 5:20 and found it locked.

A friend said the locked gate caused Jonah to miss the bus. The bus left at 5:10. The gate locked at 5:15. An event at 5:15 cannot be the cause of an event at 5:10. The order will not allow it. A later lock does not reach backward and send an earlier bus away.

What the times support is limited. The pause in the stairwell put Jonah at a locked gate at 5:20. The missed bus is a separate fact, and it is earlier than the lock. Two disappointments share a Tuesday. The later one did not produce the earlier one.

  1. 97.When does the school gate lock?

  2. 98.When does the late bus leave, relative to the lock?

  3. 99.Why can the lock not be the cause of the missed bus?

  4. 100.What do the times support about Jonah and the gate?

  5. 101.How does the passage relate the missed bus to the locked gate?

  6. 102.What error does the friend make?

A Bag Is Not a Shelf

A letter against the library's phone rule says that asking students to keep phones in their bags is the same as banning books. The letter wants that likeness to carry the argument. The likeness does not hold.

A book on the open shelf may be read in the room. The desk card asks students to keep phones in bags during the silent hour. The rule limits phones for that hour. It does not remove books, close the catalog, or send a reader out of the room. Sameness would require the same act. Putting a phone in a bag and removing books from the shelves are not the same act.

The feeling of being limited is real, and the letter is right that a rule sets a limit. A limit on a device during one hour is not a ban on the collection. The analogy moves the alarm people feel about banning books onto a rule about bags. The library can keep the silent hour and keep the shelves. One limit does not become the other because both can be called a limit.

  1. 103.What likeness does the letter claim?

  2. 104.Why does the passage say the two acts are not the same?

  3. 105.What does the passage concede to the letter?

  4. 106.What does the passage say the analogy does?

  5. 107.What does the passage say the library can do at the same time?

  6. 108.What test of sameness does the passage use?